Welcome to OddFellows Ice Cream Co.
OddFellows Ice Cream Co., nestled in Brooklyn's DUMBO neighborhood, is a delightful blend of nostalgia and innovation in the ice cream realm. With a menu that boasts both classic and imaginative flavors, such as the Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio and the unique Peanut Butter S'mores, there's something for everyone, including a robust selection of vegan options. Patrons can indulge in a welcoming atmosphere complete with dog-friendly spaces and various amenities like free Wi-Fi and delivery. Whether you're savoring a scoop on a sunny afternoon or enjoying a milkshake made from their homemade ice cream, OddFellows captures the essence of joyful indulgence in every bite.
OddFellows Ice Cream Co.: Reviews & Ratings
A great ice cream spot down by the water. All the flavors we sampled were good. They also had 5 vegan options. Cookie jar was the choice I chose, although they didnt have chocotorta, which is odd since the Domino Park location usually has ...
Good ice cream with a very unique variety of flavors. Kind of a retro feeling store front and nice vibes. Had the coffee ice cream with coffee grinds with a chocolate waffle cone. Plenty of choices to choose from whether you like something fruity or chocolatey. Great stop in Dumbo. ...
Excellent desserts destination in the neighborhood of DUMBO. They offer both dairy and vegan options with wonderfully unique flavors. ...
Popped by on a sunny Sunday afternoon and got some ice creams and a break from the afternoon heat. I got the raspberry rose cider flavour which was delicious. Perfect spot for an ice cream and a stroll along the harbour on a nice day!
the pistachio soft serve was some of the best ice cream ive ever had! i wish theyd keep this year round
Totally recommended if your in the area, theres a few other ice cream shops around but I havent try those, but this one.. it was really good!! We tried the Chocolate Chunk Flavor and Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio, my ...
Ordered a cool flavor called Fiery Fruity Frenemy and was super anxious because it could go all wrong but ended up with a refreshing light ice cream flavor with an interesting dance between mango and guava What a nice name it has!. I do ...
Amazing ice cream, good number of options 17 flavors including 5 vegan options 3 sorbets, decent prices, a great deal with flight option 6 reasonable mini scoops for 10 and a minute away from Dumbo viewpoints parks where you can ...
Location
-
44 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Hotline: (718) 683-5755
Welcome to OddFellows Ice Cream Co., a delightful gem nestled by the waterfront in Brooklyn’s vibrant DUMBO neighborhood. Known for its innovative flavors and inviting atmosphere, OddFellows stands out as a must-visit destination for ice cream lovers.
The brand prides itself on crafting artisanal ice creams that push the boundaries of creativity. With a delicious array of offerings, the menu includes unique fan favorites such as Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio, featuring a creamy base complemented by candied apricots and crunchy pistachios, and the rich, indulgent Peanut Butter S'mores, a collaborative flavor with the iconic band LCD Soundsystem, which marries peanut butter ice cream with graham cracker crumbs, dark chocolate, and burnt marshmallows.
- Location: 44 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
- Phone: (718) 683-5755
For those who embrace diverse diets, OddFellows does not disappoint, offering a selection of vegan options alongside their indulgent dairy choices. The atmosphere is equally accommodating, featuring wheelchair accessibility and a space where you can bring your canine companions. Plus, the availability of delivery, takeout, and even a drive-thru ensures that you can enjoy your ice cream fix wherever you are!
As you step into OddFellows, you'll find a nostalgic vibe with a retro storefront, perfect for a leisurely stroll along the harbor. Patrons have raved about the varied flavor selection, from fruity to chocolatey, perfectly complementing a sunny afternoon. Customer reviews highlight experiences like trying the enigmatic raspberry rose cider flavor or the outstanding pistachio soft serve, with many expressing wishes for year-round availability of their favorites.
Whether you're in the mood for a classic ice cream sandwich made with chewy chocolate chip cookies or exploring their scrumptious add-ons like freshly made waffle cones, OddFellows Ice Cream Co. promises an experience that’s both satisfying and unforgettable. So, embark on your culinary adventure at OddFellows, where every scoop tells a story and each visit feels like a celebration of flavor!
